Author Topic: Best bicycle tracker or air tag  (Read 24663 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline dayjack119

  • World Traveler
  • *****
  • Posts: 125
  • 2025 Key West to DC 'DOGE' Bike Tour
Best bicycle tracker or air tag
« on: April 24, 2025, 12:58:55 pm »
I've just invested some serious dough on an electric touring bike and would like to know what is the best tracker to hide on the frame somewhere?  Price doesn't matter in the long run.  Would appreciate your input.

Offline John Nettles

  • World Traveler
  • *****
  • Posts: 2065
  • I ride for smiles, not miles.
Re: Best bicycle tracker or air tag
« Reply #1 on: April 24, 2025, 01:59:42 pm »
Historically people put a note saying this bike belongs to "Name, address, phone, email" in a few places, such as inside the handlebar tubes or the frame's seat tube or bottom bracket, between tire/tube, etc. Some went so far as to put a "dummy" tag on an easily seen location (top tube) in the hope the thief would see that feel all is OK after finding it.

However, with the advent of the the airtag, I don't know if the tag would a) fit inside inside those places and b) if it does, if the tag's signal could get through.   

I would experiment in places like under the seat (covered in black tape), under the brake hood, maybe wrapped under bar tape (street-side of bar so doesn't interfere with hands), etc.  While touring, you could but inside a pannier I guess. 

However, all that may not matter if you do not have unique identifying marks on the bike other than the serial number if the bike is not recovered immediately before the air tag is removed.  I had a Co-Motion Americano with Rohlof (no air tag) stolen from our garage most likely by a homeless guy.  When the police took the report, I was lucky to get an officer who rode bikes.  He said if I had pictures or could describe very specific deep scratches, dents, etc. that would be hard to remove/hide otherwise it would become a he said/she said scenario and the "possessor" would win even though my specific bike (make/model/options/color) was pretty unique, especially for a state the size of Oklahoma.  Fortunately, the bike did have a small dent on the top tube.   

Months later, the bike was recovered. The thief ground off all serial numbers (bike, Rohloff, dyno hub, etc.) and spray painted the bike a different color but it was the dent that finally allowed me to get the bike back since no other identifying mark was available. If I did not have a dent, the police would not have returned it to me do to liability.

All that said, if you are touring in mostly rural USA/Canada, I would not be overly concerned.  I have toured for 45+ years with probably more than 75k miles of loaded touring and have never had a bike stolen.  Sure it could happen but most likely not.     

I always carry a "opportunity theft deterrent" bike cable (a 10-foot 1/8" vinyl coated cable with a small suitcase lock long) and use it if in doubt.  I figure a professional thief would get the bike regardless of the security measures so just try to prevent the opportunity theft by the person walking by.  The local hardware store (not big box) can make one to length if you want.  Lately, I bought a "dog tie out" cable with a thin cable and loops on Amazon so I didn't have to make one and have no issues with it.

Hope you have many great tours!  John

Offline dayjack119

  • World Traveler
  • *****
  • Posts: 125
  • 2025 Key West to DC 'DOGE' Bike Tour
Re: Best bicycle tracker or air tag
« Reply #2 on: April 24, 2025, 03:24:37 pm »
Hey, John.  Thanks for taking the time to assist me.  This summer is my thirteenth tour and I have had no trouble all this time with the exception of some homeless guys messing with my gear until I chased them away.  But it seems these days that things are much less safe for cyclists like me with grey hair and white skin.  I never felt that way before but now I avoid large cities.  You've given me some good ideas.  Thanks again, Jack Day

Offline kizarmynot

Re: Best bicycle tracker or air tag
« Reply #3 on: April 24, 2025, 07:24:43 pm »
Consider searching online for bike air tag items. I've seen water bottle holders with air tag holders hidden and other items that would normally be on a bike. If you decide to hide it in the frame, you may want to do a test to check that it works in the location. GPLama (YouTube) did a test a while back that may be helpful too.

Offline canalligators

Re: Best bicycle tracker or air tag
« Reply #4 on: May 05, 2025, 01:14:42 am »
Note that Airtags don’t work inside metal.  I considered hiding one in my carbon frame, but I’m not interested in pulling the crank or head for annual battery changes.  The most popular holders go under a bottle cage or on the seatpost bolts under the seat.

Offline froze

Re: Best bicycle tracker or air tag
« Reply #5 on: May 11, 2025, 11:47:44 pm »
But there is one that does work inside metal, in fact it goes inside the handlebar, curved or straight, it's called Sherlock GPS Bicycle Tracker that cost roughly $210 in the US.  It works with your smartphone and requires an app that is free for the first 2 years than after that you'll have to pay a fee, but it only runs for 7 days off of one charge.

There is another one that is hidden under the water bottle cage, it's called the Boomerang Cyclotrac V2, this thing will run for up to 2 months on a charge, and it also has an alarm...problem with the alarm is now the theft knows where its at!  But it does come with 2 tamper proof bolts.  It's another one of those you need a smartphone and pay a monthly fee for the app.

Similar to the Boomerang is the Knog Scout Bike Alarm and Finder, it looks the same, mounts the same except it's just an alarm, no tracker, but it will notify your smartphone, Apple only, if the alarm goes off.  This is the least expensive system at around $65.  Evidently the new version of the Knog does have a tracker, so you have to make sure you are getting the newest version.  The tracking system uses Apple's Find My app.  It comes with a neoprene cover, but they say it's not necessary to put on, and because it's yellow it will stand out much quicker than the black case it has, I guess if you're going to be getting that area of the bike muddy it might be a good idea, but the unit is water resistant without it.